Michael Smolens: Will San Diego Refocus on Preserving Neighborhoods Amid Reforms to ADU Policies?
Former top city planner Michael Stepner says more housing is needed but it should be compatible with existing communities
By Michael Smolens / San Diego Union-Tribune / May 9, 2025
The city of San Diego is downshifting on its permissive rules encouraging backyard apartments.
That raises the question of whether a desire for more “gentle development” will spread to some of the city’s other aggressive housing policies.
Last week, the city Planning Commission strongly supported an effort to roll back some of the extreme aspects of the backyard apartment program.
Several years ago, when the city began loosening restrictions on building accessory dwelling units, as they’re officially called, the idea seemed to be one or two apartments on a single-family-home property, possibly three in some cases.
Projects with double-digit units allowed under the laws aren’t what people had in mind. For example, one ADU development in Clairemont has 17 apartments, and even larger projects are in the pipeline, particularly in Encanto.
“This is not the way I envisioned ADUs would work,” Commissioner Ken Malbrough said, as reported by David Garrick of The San Diego Union-Tribune. “I want housing, but I don’t want to ruin neighborhoods.”

Edited From Neighbors for a Better San Diego
A Rag reader just recently noticed that the Blick Art Materials store in Little Italy (a large, two-story space at 1844 India Street) would be closing and relocating to the large space that was recently vacated by Joann Fabrics at 3633 Midway Drive in the Point Loma Plaza shopping center.
See inside for specifics if you plan on attending the meeting.
A 51-year-old male pedestrian died Saturday, May 10, after being struck by a car in the Midway District. The as-yet-to-be identified man was crossing the street outside of a crosswalk in the 3400 block of Sports Arena Boulevard.
There’s a brand new community coalition in San Diego that is already making waves. It’s called the San Diego
There was an armed robbery attempt at one of OB’s high-end restaurants Saturday night, May 3. Apparently, the robbery at Cesarina was unsuccessful and no one was hurt. Here’s how the restaurant described the event on Instagram:
By Colleen O’Connor
By Olivia Harden /
By Steve O San Diego
By Joni Halpern




Recent Comments