Open Letter to Congressman Scott Peters and Calif Senator Akilah Weber: Dem Leaders, Get a Clue: YIMBYism Is NOT Progressive

By Lu Rehling
Question for our elected representatives US Congressman Scott Peters and CA Senator Akilah Weber: Who does this sound like to you when it comes to advocating for changes to housing policy?
- Bypass environmental and safety protections.
- Blame regulations [not developer/corporate greed].
- Apply trickle-down economics [newly applied to the housing market].
- Promote gentrification [driving mid- to lower-income resident out of their homes].
- Encourage short-term rentals [discouraging starter home ownership].
- Off-site affordable housing [so only the entitled enjoy exclusive perks and only with each other].
- Disenfranchise community groups [by waiving reviews and defunding appeals].
- Ignore the needs of disabled and families [prioritizing transport options for the fit and unencumbered].
If your answer is “progressives,” then read your Orwell, because progressive policy instead asks government to tackle inequality and promote social justice. And yet you align with so-called progressive YIMBY Dems.
In fact, Congressman Peters, you co-sponsored and continue to smugly tout the “Build More Housing Near Transit Act” legislation that would enable all of the policies stated above, allowing “by-right” density development: the “right” being to waive height, parking, and safety review requirements.
Of course, being a politician, you also say that you favor “community input,” but that’s NOT in the law that you’ve proposed. And its affordability and building reuse inclusions are minimalist-to-toothless: options, not mandates that developers, laser-focused as usual on their own self-interested goals, can freely ignore.
And, in fact, Senator Weber, you approved passage from committee of SB 79 (“Housing Development: Transit Oriented Development”) that would do the much of the same as Peters’ proposal, similarly without urgently needed and appropriate safeguards.

Over 100 San Diego residents from all over the city rallied in Clairemont on Saturday, August 23, against Senate Bill 79 – a bill sponsored by State Senator Scott Wiener that targets the state’s neighborhoods. Opponents claim that the bill is worse than SB 9 and SB 10.
By Steven Harper /
By Aaron Pellish /
By Sara Jacobs /
by Noah Goldberg /
By Tanja Kropf /
by Dave Schwab /
Washington DC, America’s bluest city, is building more homes per capita than Houston—not with bottom-up zoning reform but with top-down government action.
If Trump is taking tactical advice from Putin about how to hold an election, that doesn’t bode well for the future of American democracy.
By Neighbors for a Better California Board
By Francine Maxwell




Recent Comments