Opening Salvo by Joe Biden on Eve of 3rd Anniversary of Fascist Coup Attempt: ‘Who Are We?’

by on January 7, 2024 · 21 comments

in Civil Rights, Election

By Joe Biden, President

Today — the topic of my speech today is deadly serious, and I think it needs to be made at the outset of this campaign.

In the winter of 1777, it was harsh and cold as the Continental Army marched to Valley Forge.  General George Washington knew he faced the most daunting of tasks: to fight and win a war against the most powerful empire that existed in the world at the time.

His mission was clear.  Liberty, not conquest.  Freedom, not domination.  National independence, not individual glory.

America made a vow.  Never again would we bow down to a king.

The months ahead would be incredibly difficult.  But General Washington knew something in his bones, something about the spirit of the troops he was leading, something — something about the soul of the nation he [that] was struggling to be born.

In his general order, he predicted, and I quote, “with one heart and one mind,” “with fortitude and with patience,” they would overcome every difficulty — the troops he was leading.

And they did.  They did.

This army that lacked blankets and food, clothes and shoes.  This army whose march left bloody, bare footprints in the snow.  This ragtag army made up of ordinary people.  Their mission, George Washington declared, was nothing less than “a sacred cause.”  That was the phrase used: “a sacred cause.”

Freedom, liberty, democracy.  American democracy.

I just visited the grounds of Valley Forge.  I’ve been there a number of times from the time I was a Boy Scout years ago.  You know, it’s the very site that I think every American should visit because it tells the story of the pain and the suffering and the true patriotism it took to make America.

Today, we gather in a new year, some 246 years later, just one day before January 6th, a day forever shared in our memory because it was on that day that we nearly lost America — lost it all.

Today, we’re here to answer the most important of questions.  Is democracy still America’s sacred cause?  I mean it.  (Applause.)

This is not rhetorical, academic, or hypothetical.  Whether democracy is still America’s sacred cause is the most urgent question of our time, and it’s what the 2024 election is all about.

The choice is clear.  Donald Trump’s campaign is about him, not America, not you.  Donald Trump’s campaign is obsessed with the past, not the future.  He’s willing to sacrifice our democracy, put himself in power.

Our campaign is different.  For me and Kamala, our campaign is about America.  It’s about you.  It’s about every age and background that occupy this country.  It’s about the future we’re going to continue to build together.

And our campaign is about preserving and strengthening our American democracy.  Three years ago tomorrow, we saw with our own eyes the violent mob storm the United States Capitol.  It was almost in disbelief as you first turned on the television.

For the first time on our history, insurrectionists had come to stop the peaceful tranfer — transfer of power in America — first time — smashing windows, shattering doors, attacking the police.

Outside, gallows were erected as the MAGA crowd chanted, “Hang Mike Pence.”

Inside, they hunted for Speaker Pelosi [of] the House, was chanting, as they marched through and smashed windows, “Where’s Nancy?”

Over 140 police officers were injured.  Jill and I attended the funeral of police officers who died as a result of the events of that day.

And because Donald — because of Donald Trump’s lies, they died because these lies brought a mob to Washington.

He promised it would be “wild,” and it was.  He told the crowd to “fight like hell,” and all hell was unleashed.

He promised he would right them — right them.  Everything they did, he would be side by side with them.  Then, as usual, he left the dirty work to others.  He retreated to the White House.

As America was attacked from within, Donald Trump watched on TV in the private small dining room off my Oval — off the Oval Office.

The entire nation watched in horror.  The whole world watched in disbelief.  And Trump did nothing.

Members of his staff, members of his family, Republican leaders who were under attack for the — at that very moment pled with him: “Act.  Call off the mob.”

Imagine had he gone out and said, “Stop.”

And still, Trump did nothing.  It was among the worst derelictions of duty by a president in American history: an attempt to overturn a free and fair election by force and violence.

A record 81 million people voted for my candidacy and to end his presidency.  Trump lost the popular vote by 7 million.

Trump’s claims about the 2020 election never could stand up in court.  Trump lost 60 court cases — 60.  Trump lost the Republican-controlled states.  Trump lost before a Trump-appointed judge — and then judges.  And Trump lost before the United States Supreme Court.  (Applause.)  All of it, he lost.

Trump lost recount after recount after recount in state after state.  But in desperation and weakness, Trump and his MAGA followers went after election officials who en- — who ensured your power as a citizen would be heard.  These public servants had their lives forever upended by attacks and death threats for simply doing their jobs.

In Atlanta, Georgia, a brave Black mother and her daughter, Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss, were doing their jobs as elected workers until Donald Trump and his MAGA followers targeted and threatened them, forcing them from their homes and unleashing racist vitriol on them.  Trump’s personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, was just hit with $148 million judgment for cruelty and defamation that he inflicted against them.

Other state and local elected officials across the country faced similar personal attacks.  In addition, Fox News agreed to pay a record $8- — $787 million for the lies they told about voter fraud.

Let’s be clear about the 2020 election.  Trump exhausted every legal avenue available to him to overturn the election — every one.  But the legal path just took Trump back to the truth that I had won the election and he was a loser.  (Applause.)

Well, knowing how his mind works now, he had one — he had one act left — one desperate act available to him: the violence of January the 6th.

And since that day, more than 1,200 people have been charged for their assault on the Capitol.  Nearly 900 of them have been convicted or pled guilty.  Collectively, to date, they have been sentenced to more than 840 years in prison.  (Applause.)

And what has Trump done?  Instead of calling them “criminals,” he’s called these exsurrec- — these insurrectionists “patriots.”  They’re “patriots.”  And he promised to pardon them if he returns to office.

Trump said that there was “a lot of love” on January the 6th.  The rest of the nation, including law enforcement, saw a lot of hate and violence.  One Capitol police officer called it a “medieval battle.”  That same officer called vile — was called vile, racist names.

He said he was more afraid in the Capitol of the United States of America, in the chambers, than when he was fighting as a soldier in the war in Iraq.  He said he was more afraid inside the halls of Congress than fighting in the war in Iraq.

In trying to rewrite the facts of January 6th, Trump is trying to steal history the same way he tried to steal the election.  But he — we knew the truth because we saw it with our own eyes.  It wasn’t like something — a story being told.  It was on television repeatedly.  We saw it with our own eyes.

Trump’s mob wasn’t a peaceful protest.  It was a violent assault.  They were insurrectionists, not patriots.  They weren’t there to uphold the Constitution; they were there to destroy the Constitution.

Trump won’t do what an American president must do.  He refuses to denounce political violence.

So, hear me clearly.  I’ll say what Donald Trump won’t.  Political violence is never, ever acceptable in the United States political system — never, never, never.  It has no place in a democracy.  None.  (Applause.)

You can’t be pro-insurrectionist and pro-American.

You know, Trump and his MAGA supporters not only embrace political violence, but they laugh about it.  At his rally, he jokes about an intruder, whipped up by the Big Trump Lie, taking a hammer to Paul Pelosi’s skull and echoing the very same words used on January 6th: “Where’s Nancy?”

And he thinks that’s funny.  He laughed about it.  What a sick — (laughter and applause).  My God.

I think it’s despicable, seriously — not just for a president, for any person to say that.  But to say it to the whole world listening.

When I was overseas — anyway.  (Laughter.)

Trump’s assault on democracy isn’t just part of his past.  It’s what he’s promising for the future.  He’s being straightforward.  He’s not hiding the ball.

His first rally for the 2024 campaign opened with a choir of January 6th insurrectionists singing from prison on a cell phone while images of the January 6th riot played on a big screen behind him at his rally.

Can you believe that?  This is like something out of a fairy tale — a bad fairy tale.

Trump began his 2024 campaign by glorifying the failed violent insurrectionist — insurrection at our — on our Capitol.

The guy who claims law and order sows lawlessness and disorder.

Trump’s not concerned about your future, I promise you.  Trump is now promising a full-scale campaign of “revenge” and “retribution” — his words — for some years to come.  They were his words, not mine.  He went on to say he would be a dictator on day one.

I mean, if I were writing a book of fiction and I said an American president said that, and not in jest —

He called it, and I quote, the termina- — quote — this is a quote — the “termination of all the rules, regulation, and articles, even those found in the U.S. Constitution,” should be terminated, if it’s his will.

It’s really kind of hard to believe.  Even found in the Constitution, he could terminate?

He’s threatened the former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff with the death penalty.  Says he should be put to death because the Chairman put his oath to the Constitution ahead of his personal loyalty to Trump.

This coming from a president who called — when he visited a ce- — a cemetery, called dead soldiers “suckers” and “losers.”  Remember that?

Sometimes, I’m really happy the Irish in me can’t be seen.  (Laughter.)

It was right around the time I was at Beau’s grave, Tommy.

How dare he?  Who in God’s name does he think he is?

With former aides, Trump plans to invoke the Ins- — Insurrectionist Act — the Insurrection Act, which would allow him to deploy — which he’s not allowed to do in ordinary circumstances — allow him to deploy U.S. military forces on the streets of America.  He said it.

He calls those who oppo- — oppose him “vermin.”  He talks about the blood of Americans being poisoned, echoing the same exact language used in Nazi Germany.

He proudly posts on social media the words that best describe his 2024 campaign, quote, “revenge”; quote, “power”; and, quote, “dictatorship.”

There’s no confusion about who Trump is and what he intends to do.

I placed my hand on our family Bible, and I swore an oath on the very same steps of the Capitol just 14 days after the attack on January the 6th.

As I looked out over the capital city, whose streets were lined with National Guard to prevent another attack, I saw an American that had been pushed to the brink — an America that had been pushed to the brink.

But I felt enormous pride — not in winning.  I felt enormous pride in America because American democracy had been tested and American democracy had held together.  And when Trump had seen weakness in our democracy and continues to talk about it, I saw strength — your strength.  It’s not hyperbole.  Your strength.  Your integrity.  American strength and integrity.

Ordinary citizens, state election officials, the American judicial system had put the Constitution first and sometimes at their peril — at their peril.

Because of them, because of you, the will of the people prevailed, not the anger of the mob or the appetites of one man.

When the attack on January 6th happened, there was no doubt about the truth.  At the time, even Republican members of Congress and Fox News commentators publicly and privately condemned the attack.

As one Republican senator said, “Trump’s behavior was embarrassing and humiliating for the country.”  But now, that same senator and those same people have changed their tune.

As time has go one — gone on, politics, fear, money, all have intervened.  And now these MAGA voices who know the truth about Trump on January 6th have abandoned the truth and abandoned democracy.

They made their choice.  Now the rest of us — Democrats, independents, mainstream Republicans — we have to make our choice.

I know mine.  And I believe I know America’s.

We will defend the truth, not give in to the Big Lie.  We’ll embrace the Constitution and the Declaration, not abandon it.  We’ll honor the sacred cause of democracy, not walk away from it.

Today, I make this sacred pledge to you.  The defense, protection, and preservation of American democracy will remain, as it has been, the central cause of my presidency.  (Applause.)

America, as we begin this election year, we must be clear: Democracy is on the ballot.  Your freedom is on the ballot.  (Applause.)

Yes, we’ll be voting on many issues: on the freedom to vote and have your vote counted, on the freedom of choice, the freedom to have a fair shot, the freedom from fear.  And we’ll debate and disagree.

Without democracy, no progress is (inaudible) possible.  Think about it.  The alternative to democracy is dictatorship — the rule of one, not the rule of “We the People.”

That’s what the soldiers of Valley Forge understood.  And so was me — was what we have to understand it as well.  We’ve been blessed so long with a strong, stable democracy.  It’s easy to forget why so many before us risked their lives and strengthened democracy, what our lives would be without it.

Democracy means having the freedom to speak your mind, to be who you are, to be who you want to be.  Democracy is about being able to bring about peaceful change.  Democracy — democracy is how we’ve opened the doors of opportunity wider and wider with each successive generation, notwith- — notwithstanding our mistakes.

But if democracy falls, we’ll lose that freedom.  We’ll lose the power of “We the People” to shape our destiny.  If you doubt me, look around the world.  Travel with me as I meet with other heads of state throughout the world.

Look at the authoritarian leaders and dictators Trump says he admires — he, out loud, says he admires.  I won’t go through them all.  It would take too long.

Look, remember how he fers- — when he — when he refers to what he calls the “love letter” exchanges between he and the dictator of North Korea?  Those women and men out there in the audience who ever fought for the American military, would you ever believe you’d hear a president say something like that?

His admiration for Putin — I can go on.

And look at what these autocrats are doing to limit freedom in their countries.  They’re limiting freedom of speech, freedom of press, freedom to assemble, women’s rights, LGB[T]Q rights, people are going to jail, so much more.

It’s true: The push and pull of American history is not a fairy tale.  Every stride forward in America is met with a ferocious backlash, many times from those who fear progress and those who exploit that fear for their own personal gain; from those who traffic in lies told for power and profit; from those who are driven by grievance and grift, consumed by conspiracy and victimhood; from those who seek to bury history and ban books.

Did you ever think you’d be at a political event talking about book banning for a presidential — in a presidential election?

The choice and contest between those forces — those competing forces, between solidarity and division — is perennial.  But this time, it’s so different.

You can’t have a contest — you can’t have a contest if you see politics as an all-out war instead of a peaceful way to resolve our differences.  All-out war is what Trump wants.

That’s why he doesn’t understand the most fundamental truth about this country.  Unlike other nations on Earth, America is not built on ethnicity, religion, geography.  We’re the only nation in the history of the world built on an idea — not hyperbole — built on an idea: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men and women are created equal.”

It’s an idea declared in the Declaration, created in a way that we viewed everybody as equal and be — should be treated equally throughout their lives.

We’ve never fully lived up to that.  We have a long way to go.  But we’ve never walked away from the idea.  We’ve never walked away from it before.  But I promise you, I will not let Donald Trump and the MAGA Republicans — (applause) — force us to walk away now.

We’re living in an era where a determined minority is doing everything in its power to try to destroy our democracy for their own agenda.  The American people know it, and they’re standing bravely in the breach.

Remember, after 2020, January 6th insurrection to undo the election in which more Americans had voted than any other in American history?  America saw the threat posed to the country, and they voted him out.  In 2022, historic midterm election, in state after state, election after election, the election deniers were defeated.

Now, in 2024, Trump in running as the “denier-in-chief” — the election denier-in-chief.  Once again, he’s saying he won’t honor the results of the election if he loses.

Trump says he doesn’t understand.  Well, he still doesn’t understand the basic truth, and that is you can’t love your country only when you win.  (Applause.)  You can’t love your country only when you win.

So, I’ll keep my commitment to be president for all of America, whether you voted for me or not.  I’ve done it for the last three years, and I’ll continue to do it.

Together, we can keep proving that America is still a country that believes in decency, dignity, honesty, honor, truth.  We still believe that no one, not even the President, is above the law.  We still believe — (applause) — the vast majority of us still believe that everyone deserves a fair shot at making it.  We’re still a nation that gives hate no safe harbor.

I tell you from my experience working with leaders around the world — and I mean this sincerely, not a joke — that America is still viewed as the beacon of democracy for the world.

I can’t tell you how many — how many world leaders — and I know all of them, virtually all of them — grab my arm in private and say, “He can’t win.  Tell me.  No, my country will be at risk.”

Think of how many countries, Tommy, you know that are on the br- — on the edge.  Imagine.

We still believe in “We the People,” and that includes all of us, not some of us.

Let me close with this.  On that cold winter of 1777, George Washington and his American troops at Valley Forge waged a battle on behalf of a revolutionary idea that everyday people — like where I come from and the vast majority of you — not a king or a dictator — that everyday people can govern themselves without a king or a dictator.

In fact, in the rotunda of the Capitol, there’s a giant painting of General George Washington — not President Washington — and he is resigning his commission as Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army.

A European king at this — at the time said, after he won the revolution, “Now is the time for him to declare his kingship.”

But instead, the mob that attacked the Capitol, waving Trump flags and Confederate flags, stormed right past that portrait.  That image of George Washington gave them no pause, but it should have.

The artist that painted that portrait memorialized that moment because he said it was, quote, “one of the highest moral lessons ever given to the world.”  End of quote.

George Washington was at the height of his power.  Having just defeated the most powerful empire on Earth, could have held onto the power as long as he wanted.  He could have made himself not a future president but a future monarch, in effect.

And, by the way, when he got elected president, he could have stayed for two, three, four, five terms, until he died.  But that wasn’t the America he and the American troops at Valley Forge had fought for.

In America, genuine leaders — democratic leaders, with a small “d” — don’t hold on to power relentlessly.  Our leaders return power to the people.  And they do it willingly, because that’s the deal.  You do your duty.  You serve your country.

And ours is a country worther- — worthy of service, as many Republican presidents and Democratic presidents have shown over the years.

We’re not perfect.  But at our best, we face on — we face head on the good, the bad, the truth of who we are.  We look in the mirror and ultimately never pretend we’re something we’re not.  That’s what great nations do.  And we’re a great nation.  We’re the greatest nation on the face of the Earth.  We really are.  (Applause.)

That’s the America I see in our future.  We get up.  We carry on.  We never bow.  We never bend.  We speak of possibilities, not carnage.  We’re not weighed down by grievances.  We don’t foster fear.  We don’t walk around as victims.

We take charge of our destiny.  We get our job done with our peop- — the help of the people we find in America, who find their place in the changing world and dream and build a future that not only they but all people deserve a shot at.

We don’t believe — none of you believe America is failing.  We know America is winning.  That’s American patriotism.  (Applause.)

And it’s not winning because of Joe Biden.  It’s winning.

This is the first national election since January 6th insurrection placed a dagger at the throat of American democracy — since that moment.  We all know who Donald Trump is.  The question we have to answer is: Who are we?  That’s what’s at stake.  (Applause.)  Who are we?

In the year ahead, as you talk to your family and friends, cast your ballots, the power is in your hands.  After all we’ve been through in our history, from independence to Civil War to two world wars to a pandemic to insurrection, I refuse to believe that, in 2024, we Americans will choose to walk away from what’s made us the greatest nation in the history of the world: freedom, liberty.  (Applause.)

Democracy is still a sacred cause.  And there’s no country in the world better positioned to lead the world than America.

That’s why — (applause) — I’ve said it many times.  That’s why I’ve never been more optimistic about our future.  And I’ve been doing this a hell of a long time.  (Laughter.)

Just have to remember who we are — with patience and fortitude, with one heart.  We are the United States of America, for God’s sake.  (Applause.)

I mean it.  There is nothing — I believe with every fiber that there is nothing beyond our capacity if we act together and decently with one another.  Nothing, nothing, nothing.  (Applause.)  I mean it.

We’re the only nation in the world that’s come out of every crisis stronger than we went into that crisis.  That was true yesterday and it’s true today, and I guarantee you will be true tomorrow.

God bless you all.  And may God protect our troops.  (Applause.)

Thank you.  Thank you.

(The First Lady joins the President onstage.)  I understand power.  (Laughter.)

Thank you all so very much.  (Inaudible.)  Thank you, thank you, thank you.  (Applause.)

{ 21 comments… read them below or add one }

Gilbert Field January 7, 2024 at 11:57 am

Powerful words.
Biden must win in 2024 or we will become just another totalitarian dictatorship.

Reply

Sean Reilly January 8, 2024 at 7:32 am

Thanks for printing the entirety of Biden’s speech. Excellent to read!

Reply

Frank Gormlie January 8, 2024 at 11:22 am

Here’s Bernie Sanders:
“Three years ago today, a violent mob stormed the United States Capitol with the hope of overturning the results of the presidential election. The images Americans saw that day made visibly clear what many of us have realized for a long time:

Our democracy was under severe attack.

But the truth is that the attack on our democracy goes far deeper than the violence of January 6, 2021 and right-wing authoritarians like Donald Trump.

Our democracy is under attack from Republicans in Congress and in state legislatures across the country who are doing everything in their power to suppress the vote and make it harder for people of color and young people to vote. These political cowards are also engaging in extreme gerrymandering and are drawing the lines of their districts so they pick their voters instead of voters picking their representatives. They are intent on establishing permanent majorities.

Our democracy is under attack when many Republicans, at all levels of government, promote the Big Lie that the presidential election was stolen and increasingly call into question the results of any election they lose.

Our democracy is under attack when election officials are being harassed and threatened and when efforts are being made to allow partisan legislatures to determine election winners and losers.

But let’s be clear. It is not just the subversion of democratic norms and voting rights that is undermining our democracy.

Our democracy is also under attack because all across this country people increasingly believe democracy itself, and our government, does not work for them.

For the vast majority of Americans there is a huge disconnect between the reality of their lives and what goes on in Washington, D.C. The people see the politicians talking, talking and talking, they watch the 30 second TV ads and they hear the promises that are made — but never kept.

They remember what Lincoln said about “government of the people, by the people and for the people,” and they know how far removed we are from that today.

They see the very rich become much richer while politicians and the corporate media ignore the collapse of the middle class and the painful realities facing working families — low wages, dead end jobs, debt, homelessness, lack of health care or educational opportunity, declining life expectancy, substance abuse, impoverished retirement.

So yes, in the year 2024 we must do everything we can to make sure Donald Trump is defeated and defeated soundly in the next election.

But, if we are really going to save democracy and make it relevant to people’s lives, we must boldly address the long-neglected crises facing the working people of this country.

In other words, dare I say, we need a government that represents the needs of ordinary Americans and not just wealthy campaign contributors.

The choice before us is whether we move into oligarchy, where our economic and political life is dominated by a handful of billionaires, or whether we create a vibrant democracy where the voices of the people are heard, and where their needs are addressed.

Nothing less than the future of our democracy is at stake.

In solidarity,

Bernie Sanders”

Reply

chris schultz January 9, 2024 at 7:09 am

The choice before us is whether we move into oligarchy.

Whether? Were already there. The tax dodgers pay their PAC consultants and lawyers. Having to pay for your politics is another tax. As bad as dotard and his elected minions need to be neutered, there is the clown crash oligarchy show in Sacramento devising new ways to tax you more. So buyer beware. You can have all the affordable housing you want mean nothing when you’re getting punked like this.

REPEAL OF PROP 13: California politicians have placed two measures on the November 2024 ballot (ACA-1 and ACA-13) to gut Prop 13 and make it easier to raise your taxes.
SALES TAX: Local politicians have placed a massive sales tax measure on the ballot that would give most residents a sales tax near 10%!
UTILITY TAX: California politicians have decided to give your private tax returns to your utility company so they can set your electricity rates based on your income. If you “earn too much” you will be required to pay more for your electricity.

Future considerations.

Mileage Tax: Politicians are already imposing a 6-cents per mile tax costing an average of $900 per car per year!
Healthcare Tax: Politicians propose to double California state taxes to fund government-run healthcare – costing average of $16k per household per year. These are the same politicians that just recklessly gave illegal immigrants billions in free taxpayer-funded health insurance!
Exit Tax: Politicians want a new tax for up to 10 years on residents who move out of California
Savings Tax: Politicians want a new tax on your personal savings and investments

Reply

Judy Swink January 9, 2024 at 10:04 am

Regarding your comment “UTILITY TAX: California politicians have decided to give your private tax returns to your utility company so they can set your electricity rates based on your income. If you “earn too much” you will be required to pay more for your electricity.”

I have wondered how SDG&E would be able – legally – to determine anyone’s income for the proposed flat rate charge. I don’t see how any legislative action can breech federal law making tax returns private unless a subpoena has been approved by a court of law.

However, if you and others are sick of the games that the investor-owned utilities like SDG&E have long played against their ratepayers, please check out the Power San Diego website for information about signing our initiative petition to require the City of San Diego to establish a publicly-owned electric utility. https://wearepowersandiego.com/ Page down to the section “How will you benefit from the Power San Diego ballot initiative?” This effort will be of particular benefit to anyone who has installed or wishes to install solar panels for their home or business.

The same web page includes, at the top, ways to sign the petition – there will be petitions, for instance, at the weekly OB Farmers Market.

Reply

chris schultz January 9, 2024 at 11:35 am

read up on AB 205

Reply

Judy Swink January 9, 2024 at 1:40 pm

It would be helpful – to me and to other readers – if you had simply provided a link or even copied and pasted relevant parts of the bill. I did find:

” For the purposes of this section and Section 739.1, the commission may authorize fixed charges for any rate schedule applicable to a residential customer account. The fixed charge shall be established on an income-graduated basis with no fewer than three income thresholds so that a low-income ratepayer in each baseline territory would realize a lower average monthly bill without making any changes in usage. The commission shall, no later than July 1, 2024, authorize a fixed charge for default residential rates.”

I see nothing explaining just how the utilities would have legal access to my state tax filings to establish my income level.

Reply

Judy Swink January 9, 2024 at 1:42 pm

A good look at the “income-based” flat rate mandated in AB205.
https://grist.org/energy/income-based-electric-bills-the-newest-utility-fight-in-california/

Reply

chris schultz January 9, 2024 at 11:44 am

Power SD says they will do 20% lower, which is still higher than LA or Sacramento. They need to do better if they are going to finance the infrastructure via a bond. The PUC and the utilities allowing the theft of solar contributions under this state government, is a sham. What is the use of innovation if it just leads you to higher prices? Not the idea of being progressive.

Reply

Judy Swink January 9, 2024 at 2:01 pm

Do you think that a 20% reduction in rates is something to sneeze at? In reality, that won’t be achieved for many years but a City of San Diego municipal utility will, at minimum, limit the ever-increasing charges for transmission of electricity and will protect solar customers from SDG&E continuously working to diminish the economic benefits that solar customers enjoy from having taken control of their own power needs. A municipal power company in the City of San Diego also will free all of us from the income-based flat rate mandated by AB205.

The public utilities of LA and Sacramento have been in place for a century or more so of course they have lower rates, they have owned the transmission lines and controlled purchases of energy for more than a century, building their infrastructure when costs to do so were immensely lower than today.

Power San Diego will have to purchase existing transmission infrastructure at a much higher cost than that required for much longer established public utilities. Why should we continue to pay a private, investor-owned utility when we could own our own public utility. Benefits will take some years to manifest directly but, in the meantime, San Diego ratepayers will continue to see SDG&E rates climb beyond the ability of large numbers of residents to afford.

For anyone interested, here’s an impressive list of existing publicly owned utilities in California: https://www.publicpower.org/public-power-california

Reply

chris schultz January 9, 2024 at 2:15 pm

Do you think a city owner water municipality that just pushed through a 20% rate increase in the next two years will thererfore protect your 20% electricity decrease when they get a hold of it? Doubt it.

My latest electric bill is higher. Why? Good question. I haven’t done a thing different. Just turned the heater on for the first time yesterday. Between the state and the city, people are not a consideration for utility extortion.

Reply

chris schultz January 9, 2024 at 2:01 pm

And the response? Another tax from Sacramento. Tax successful people more. Just run’em out of the state. Trickle down taxation.

https://news.yahoo.com/california-democrat-pushes-wealth-tax-195904573.html

Were trying not to swerve off the road with our Democracy, which I’m appalled by the lengths dotard games can be played in the justice system on common sense decisions in the 9th circuit today, but yet not counter steer so much as to run off the other side of the road.

Reply

Sorry not Sorry January 8, 2024 at 12:15 pm

While I believe the worst thing politically that could happen is Donny “I can’t tell a truth” Drumpf actually getting elected again, I have a great fear of what will happen should he NOT get elected again. I fear for what the far right will engage in next. If we think we’ve seen gerrymandering yet, I don’t think we can imagine what will happen if the Republicans lose this year.

Reply

Frank Gormlie January 8, 2024 at 2:09 pm

You’re being tremendously optimistic in thinking that it will be actually okay if he is elected because the far-right will be satisfied. Don’t count on it. If he is elected, the next day there will be a series of assassinations and kidnappings. Plus when he takes the oath, cough, cough, he will call out the military after he has imposed his own slew of generals, already being cultivated.

Reply

Sorry not Sorry January 9, 2024 at 5:33 am

Frank, maybe I did not state it well enough, I could be more clear with my words I suppose. I DID say the WORST thing that could happen is Cheeto Jesus gets elected. I hate the thought of “assassinations and kidnappings” especially being called by a “president”, but I certainly do not think that is beyond the realm of his possibility. The term $h!t storm comes to mind but I don’t think that quite articulates it.

Reply

Frank Gormlie January 9, 2024 at 7:50 am

Okay, thanks for the clarification.

Reply

Sorry not Sorry January 9, 2024 at 5:59 am

I do however, don’t think it will be a picnic if Drumpf is NOT elected. His base will be very upset. He will undoubtedly call fraud and summon his masses to do his bidding. The followers already in power in the Federal and State legislatures will, I believe take a sharper turn to the right and do all they can to win future elections. I am not sure either scenario will be a celebration.

Reply

Chris January 10, 2024 at 1:47 pm

It’s probably safe to say we’ll have another Jan 6 scenario, if not a few and maybe more deadly. We live in the times we’re in.

Reply

Judy Swink January 8, 2024 at 3:20 pm

First, thank you for posting the full transcript of President Biden’s speech on 1/5/24 as well as Bernie Sanders comments.

As for Sorry Not Sorry’s fear of what might happen if Trump is not elected…. that will be a fraction of what can be expected if that man is elected. He must have no idea of the scale and scope of what Trump and the Heritage Foundation have already made plans for implementing on Day 1, and he must not have been listening to his actual words in the past several months about revenge and retribution. Please read this overview of the Heritage Foundation’s detailed steps (100+ page document at Poject2025 dot com) for Trump to follow. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_2025

Reply

Frank Gormlie January 8, 2024 at 3:40 pm

Absolutely agree with you Judy and thanks for the link re Project 2025, the trump blueprint and vetting of the correct personnel.

Reply

chris schultz January 10, 2024 at 11:22 am

While we’re not trying to swerve off the road on our Democracy, our Governor in an attempt to fix the budget mess, would rather cut $8.5 billion from a variety of funds, including reductions to climate change and housing programs and school facilities. It also delays and defers more than $7 billion in funding for transit and intercity rail, early childhood education grants, clean energy and behavioral health housing, over Medical for undocumented immigrants.

I’m sorry, but this is the backward thinking of Sacramento that makes California not taken seriously on the national stage.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Older Article:

Newer Article: