By Scott Chipman / Times of San Diego / Oct. 30, 2026
San Diego is preparing to make one of the most consequential public-land decisions in its history. The proposed Midway Rising development would commit nearly 50 acres of publicly owned property to a private development arrangement lasting 105 years.
Before making that commitment, city leaders should answer fundamental questions about housing demand, public subsidies, infrastructure, and whether this project represents the best long-term use of irreplaceable public land.
First, where is the demonstrated demand for thousands of additional housing units?
California has experienced population declines in recent years, while San Diego’s population growth has been modest. Meanwhile, thousands of apartments have recently been constructed throughout the region, with additional developments underway.
Where is the independent analysis demonstrating that San Diego needs this concentration of new housing at this location? How much demand represents genuine population growth versus residents simply relocating from existing neighborhoods?
Relocation doesn’t necessarily create new housing demand. It can leave vacancies elsewhere, potentially undermining existing neighborhoods and property values.
Second, what does “affordable housing” actually mean, and who pays for it?
Midway Rising promises approximately 2,000 affordable housing units. But affordability is not free. Construction, financing, maintenance and operating costs must be paid by someone.
Project financing documents contemplate substantial public subsidies, including federal tax credits and other financing mechanisms.
Who ultimately bears these costs? Federal taxpayers? State taxpayers? San Diego residents? What happens if anticipated subsidies become unavailable?
More importantly, what income levels qualify for these apartments, and how long will affordability restrictions remain enforceable?
The public deserves a transparent accounting of the actual cost per affordable unit, the sources of subsidies, and the financial obligations that may ultimately fall upon taxpayers.
Third, how will an already congested transportation network accommodate thousands of additional residents and a major entertainment arena?
The Midway District has limited major access routes, including Sports Arena Boulevard, Midway Drive, Rosecrans Street and West Point Loma Boulevard. Connections to Interstates 5 and 8 already experience substantial congestion.
Adding thousands of residents, their vehicles, delivery traffic and arena visitors raises serious questions about circulation and emergency access.
An arena event coinciding with evening commuter traffic could create particularly difficult conditions.
Promoting transit use does not eliminate these concerns. The nearest trolley stations are not conveniently located for many residents and arena patrons.
Where is the comprehensive, independently verified transportation plan demonstrating that these impacts can be adequately addressed?
Fourth, who pays for the necessary infrastructure?
Project proponents describe hundreds of millions of dollars in infrastructure improvements. But headline figures can obscure important distinctions between improvements serving the development itself and improvements benefiting the surrounding community.
How much funding is actually committed to off-site roads, intersections, utilities, drainage, and emergency access?
If tax-increment financing or other public financing mechanisms are contemplated, what future tax revenues might be committed to supporting this development?
Those revenues could otherwise support essential municipal services and infrastructure throughout San Diego.
The public needs to understand the full financial arrangement before surrendering control of this property for more than a century.
Finally, why has the city failed to seriously consider a major public park?
Great cities recognize that public open space becomes increasingly valuable as surrounding neighborhoods grow denser.
New York has Central Park. San Francisco has Golden Gate Park. San Diego has Balboa Park.
The Midway property offers an extraordinary opportunity to establish another major urban park serving Point Loma, Pacific Beach, Ocean Beach, Mission Valley and surrounding communities.
Imagine a beautifully landscaped Midway Park with recreational facilities, walking and cycling paths, athletic fields, gardens and gathering places accessible to everyone.
Such a park could become an enduring public asset rather than another densely developed neighborhood.
Once this land is committed to development, that opportunity may disappear for generations.
San Diego should not confuse development activity with genuine public benefit.
Private developers understandably seek profitable projects. City government, however, has a different responsibility: protecting the long-term interests of its citizens.
If additional housing density eventually becomes necessary, surrounding development opportunities will remain. But the opportunity to establish a major public park on nearly 50 acres of publicly owned land may never return.
Indeed, as San Diego becomes denser, the need for such a park will only increase.
Before committing this extraordinary public asset for 105 years, city leaders should demonstrate why another massive housing development serves San Diego better than a permanent public park.
The burden of proof belongs to those proposing to give up that opportunity—not to the citizens asking that it be preserved.
Scott Chipman is a 55-year resident of Pacific Beach, a community activist, parent and ex-PTA president, planning group member, co-founder and board member of SavePB and founder of San Diegans for Responsible Planning.





I’ve read his posts over the years. He’s informed & thoughtful.
The word “affordable”, is used as a joke by politicians. What’s affordable for them is NOT affordable for a minimum wage earner by a long shot. And it will never be affordable to the working class people with a family, if the rent for a 2 bdrm. starts at $3,800 per month. With the purchase of the single family lot, average is 1M, Permits, then the demo expense, dirt work, construction, with construction loan pymts. + interest every month that goes on the duration of the construction. Then the permanent financing of the loan + interest. What people don’t understand is the developer had to know the cost of the project before he/she bought the property and what the units would rent for plus maint.. trash service, water and electric monthly costs. all of that has to be figured out prior to the purchase of the property. Developers get all kinds of perks from the City for designating a very small percentage of the units as “affordable”. One development in the college area has 171 units, and only 11 “affordable”, and the bulk of the units are calculated at fair market value. “Affordable” is a word game to the politicians, City DSD, and developers. AND they no longer have to provide on-site parking to allow for more units. I predict to see a lot of them go belly up. Take a look at El Cajon blvd. through North Park and they all have for rent/lease signs and have had some of them for at least a year.
The almost $1.6 Billion costs for the 2,000 Affordable Housing Units will be fully paid for by taxpayers only. We are self-funding our own affordable housing at an excessive cost to taxpayers.
The 2,000 Affordable Housing Units can be build at the proposed City Hall redevelopment and housing project in downtown instead that needs the public funding.
10/16/2026 Land Use and Housing Item 6.
Large file. 1,121 Pages.
https://tinyurl.com/20261016a
Page 8 shows that the Affordable Housing will cost $1.588 Billion which is 37.6% of costs.
This equates to $794,000 per Affordable Housing Unit.
Page 395 is the Affordable Housing Financing Strategy which only includes public financing including Tax Credits, Bond Financing, and taxpayer grants. No where does it say that the developer will pay any of their own money for the 2,000 Affordable Housing Units.
This building nightmare has hit North Park and Hillcrest like a ton of bricks. There are now hundreds and hundreds of empty apartments, literally blights on our landscape. I can see on Zillow, there are over 900 of them for rent. And they are still building, ripping down homes and building. The GREED has no limits.
These ugly stacks of concrete boxes are being build on the ashes of our small single family homes as they are being bulldozed. A church just sold their soul~~ to build hundreds of apartments ON THEIR PARKING LOT, I can’t even get into the post office now.
The end result is that these MONSTROSITIES ARE LITTERING OUR STREETS, sitting empty. I no longer recognize my own neighborhood. Traffic, dozens of choke points, and lack of parking on every street. we are left to deal with consequences of zero urban planning when developers build and run. Build ’em ugly, cheap and FAST seems to be their motto. And the city planners are putting their stamp of approval and fast tracking permits. It will be interesting to see how long it takes for them to start falling down.
Homeowners/taxpayers have had to endure constant construction, noise, grime, workers parking on our streets all day, noise starting as early as 7 in morning. 30th and University is now a place to AVOID at all costs. And as soon as one nightmare ends.. the next one begins.
MAKE IT STOP.
Five foot set backs and three story conglomerates with zero parking in my SINGLE family neighborhood suck. And pleeeeze, no one is moving into these 2 bedroom boxes for $3500+ month, plus parking, plus maintenance fees, plus pet RENT and pet fees, fumigation fees, and fee fees. These management companies are WORSE than Ticketmaster. I recently heard there is a way developers that can pay a fee to totally eliminate making a couple of the units “affordable”. San Diego is starting to look more like LA everyday….
I totally agree with you, very well said. That’s why I moved out of NP, and the City of SD. There’s no way to replace the damages to what was a great community, with many charming old style buildings. Not any more. Very sad indeed.
Midway Sinking, the high speed train of San Diego.
In contrast, a couple weeks ago, I watched a Planning Commission meeting where an appeal of a 122- unit townhomes was being heard. One Commissioner asked, what is the availability at the school system? Reply was that the developer sent a letter to the schools and was assured there was some capacity for new students. But for Midway Rising no such inquiries for the 4,200 residential units – over 10,000 people. For Midway Rising there is NO consideration of an influx of students in one area on the neighborhood schools. Yes – there are charter schools, etc. – requiring transportation – have you ever witnessed pick-up/drop-off at your neighborhood school? Safe streets to bike to school? Oh please – Midway Rising is not a safe place to raise children. When your 11-year-old son is bored out of his skull and wants to go outside – where will he go? To the kiddy playground? Jump on a bus to OB? No adult recreation – no ball courts, exclusive central park for residents — like e.g., Plumosa Park. Trolley stop stabbings, people don’t want Flock cameras, e-bikers without a clue, homeless living under the Int. 5 bridge, East County residents want to go to the beach – ever see the traffic back-up on Int. 8 when drivers want to make a Right turn onto SD River bridge? Add 500 cars to that. Midway Rising will restrict CIPs throughout the rest of SD with the EIFD 45-year divestiture of tax revenue. Midway Rising is the Biggest Mistake In San Diego’s History. And the worst corruption displayed by a Mayor in SD History.
Very good article. It persuaded me to write to my city council representative the following.
A general message. Any politician who supports the Midway Rising boondoggle will require me to actively vote against them in any future election or attempt at a political appointment. This is a litmus test for many of us.
Picture 4 football fields filled with parked cars. Now put those cars on the roads every daytime hour and even more during PM peak hours in the district. Well above 2000/hour. And we will be losing a lane on Sports Arena.
https://wpdash.medianewsgroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/2026-2-26-Midway-Rising-Comment-Letter.pdf
you are missing the most important part: sewage. Don’t ever expect to flush a toilet again.
Thanks so much for this excellent analysis. It should be required reading for all councilmembers and staff. Really appreciate your taking the time to research and write this.
Thanks to all for the positive feedback.