San Diego Needs to Heed Housing Advice Given to Los Angeles: ‘Protect, Preserve, and Produce’

By Lu Rehling

The incoming mayor of Los Angeles, Nithya Raman, is getting practical progressive advice on how to make good on her campaign promise of addressing the need for more affordable housing from the non-profit advocacy group Housing is a Human Right. (HHR) And much of that advice could well be applied here in San Diego, too.

HHR is NOT like the only supposedly progressive YIMBY pressure groups: those that, suspiciously, are backed by conservative big real estate and that cultivate city consulting contracts and crony connections with local politicians. Such YIMBYs press for a trickle-down agenda: “build it tall, build it everywhere.”

Instead, HHR recognizes that flooding the rental market with expensive luxury housing offers ZERO near-term benefits for those who need affordable housing most and need it now. The pittance percentages of subsidized/technically affordable units in new massive, multi-year developments don’t come close to closing the need gap soon enough, with their long-term prospects shaky, as well.

Instead, HHR promotes the sensible 3 P’s that help people RIGHT NOW:

PROTECT renter rights.

Following the bold game plan enacted by NYC’s mayor, our Mayor (and City Council) should empower the just appointed head of San Diego’s voter-mandated Homelessness Revenue Account Citizens Oversight Committee as a key advisor on housing policy and its implementation. She and others with experience working on the frontlines of the housing affordability and homelessness crises could offer invaluable information about what’s happening on the street. Our city recently adopted a much-needed ban on automated rental price-fixing, but more needs to be done to rein in the predatory business practices of corporate landlords that dramatically increase rents for low- and middle-income tenants.

Unfortunately, the current bureaucrats leading our city’s housing policies have bought into the discredited “inside safe” approach to addressing street homelessness that has been so ineffective in LA that it helped to bring down the outgoing mayor. In our city that approach has led to the disgrace of inhumane tent camps in Balboa Park and failures such as the ill-conceived, costly, and eventually cancelled mega-shelter proposed for Kettner & Vine.

PRESERVE existing affordable housing.

Lower-rent housing often is older, owned by smaller-scale private landlords, and inhabited by long-term low- to middle-income tenants (including multi-generational families), all of which tends to naturally moderate and even stabilize rents. Maintaining this type of housing also preserves the culture and mutually supportive networks and local institutions within communities.

On the other hand, demolishing this type of established tenant housing to provide high-rises for affluent professionals and down-sizers, outside investors, and short-term vacation rentals causes skyrocketing rents community-wide, which in turn leads to gentrification and displacement.

The prevalence and ongoing spread of gentrification and displacement in San Diego’s low- to moderate-income communities (especially those with a substantial segregated non-white population) is confirmed by the recent SANDAG-sponsored study of existing conditions. Alarmingly, the analyst authors of this report describe their findings as “distressing, yet necessary to read.”

Our city leaders need to do exactly that: Heed the researchers’ recommendations regarding “robust community engagement” and “creation of a toolkit for action.” Routinely and frequently updating such displacement research also could help to head off further gentrification and displacement in both new and already affected neighborhoods.

PRODUCE the most urgently needed types of housing.

Midway Rising’s questionable promises of affordable housing would only (possibly) be fully realized decades hence. The same is true of other overly ambitiously scaled and insensitively, intrusively designed developments, too frequently approved in backroom “ministerial” deals.

As an alternative, effectively deploying adaptive reuse and modern prefab construction techniques could lead to affordable housing developments much sooner, rather than later. Seeking out and supporting such opportunities for closer-to-immediate relief should become a reoriented focus of our city leaders.

Both federal and state subsidies exist to support such developments. Currently, city staff prioritize negotiations dedicating to “penciling out” lucrative bottom lines for outside construction industry behemoths, their subs, and their financiers. City leaders could instead direct staff to actively pursue innovative opportunities, working with the new wave of vertically-integrated builders, impact-driven developers, and associated non-profit organizations.

Additionally, San Diego could lead the way by streamlining the “permit purgatory” and stifling red tape that persist in our city bureaucracy. The City Auditor and City Grand Jury already have recommended some efficiencies. And more could be designed to improve work flows and optimize scheduling both for inter-departmental and on-site inspections, simplify forms, and replace outdated legacy permitting systems. Architects and construction firms have made it clear that they would welcome such clarifying reforms.

Of course, these steps would require better management based on a commitment to change. They would NOT require sidestepping environmental investigations and safety inspections, much less sacrificing community benefits and collaboration. Those who whine that such essential protections represent just NIMBY obstructionism are dead wrong.

HHR summarizes its message succinctly:

If you can’t bring down rents, you won’t fix homelessness. The 3 P’s provide a road map for lowering tenant expenses in ways that can maximize truly affordable housing expeditiously. Let’s get our city taking steps in the right direction. We’ve seen how organized San Diego citizens and groups led the charge to reform the ADUs-on-steroids policy that disingenuously applied the granny flat label to unregulated apartment buildings.

In addition, we can continue to push for abolishing what doesn’t work, for example:

  • the disastrous Complete Communities program that destroys neighborhoods by fast- tracking developments that are not an appropriate fit for conditions on the ground
  • the flawed Progress & Preservation proposal that would gut the effectiveness of the board intended to safeguard the historic resources that enrich our communities
  • misguided policies that abet gentrification and displacement, such as development impact fees reassigned away from neighborhoods and off-siting of affordable units
  • unwarranted allowances that diminish residential quality of life, such as parking waivers based on distant and/or merely projected public transport, redefined requirements for community parks and amenities, etc.
  • weakened Community Planning Groups that, were they again provided with renewed mandates and support for their advisory roles, could deploy local experience and knowledge to collaboratively contribute to creative solutions for maintaining and increasing available affordable housing, while also maintaining healthy communities
  • the insider deal-making that gives construction union leaders and political donors more power over development decisions than city residents

Our leaders need to move the 3 P’s forward ASAP: Sensible housing policies, such as those promoted by HHR, can and should benefit all of us, our neighbors, and our city as a whole.

Lu Rehling is a resident of North Park.

Source
Author: Source

1 thought on “San Diego Needs to Heed Housing Advice Given to Los Angeles: ‘Protect, Preserve, and Produce’”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *