After the worst midterms in 50 years, you would think he’d become reasonable— but he can’t!
By Bill Eddy / Bill Eddy’s Substack / Nov 16, 2026
Last week, President Trump made it clear that he would keep the War on Iran going, wouldn’t fire Pete Hegseth, would elevate Steven Miller to Chief of Staff, would keep rounding up massive numbers of immigrants, and would keep meddling with the election results. Many people are surprised by this because the Republicans under Trump suffered the worst midterm elections in fifty years because of these policies. A change of course would seem necessary and wise. But, of course, Trump cannot do what is necessary and wise. His personality won’t allow it.
Malignant Narcissism
In 2019, Republican Governor of Massachusetts William Weld suggested that President Trump suffered from “malignant narcissism.” I wrote a blog then on PsychologyToday.com explaining what this meant: “Malignant Narcissism: Does the President Really Have It?” This is a personality that includes a combination of antisocial personality disorder (lying, conning, high-risk behavior, lack of remorse, etc.), narcissistic personality disorder (preoccupation with unlimited success, power, wealth, etc.), paranoia (everyone’s out to get me, to get us, etc.), and sadism (getting pleasure out of dominating and hurting others). In October, 2024, just before the Presidential Election, over 200 mental health professionals signed an open letter in a full-page New York Times ad stating that Trump has “malignant narcissism,” and therefore was a threat to democracy and unfit to lead.
If he has a personality disorder, this means that he has a narrow range of behavior that he will repeat and repeat regardless of the circumstances. This means he will not reflect on his own behavior and is unlikely to change. The Diagnostic Manual of mental health professionals (currently the DSM-5-TR) begins the description of personality disorders as “An enduring pattern of inner experience and behavior….” (page 734) He can’t connect the dots from his own actions to how other people react to him. In other words, he will never believe that the Republican wipe-out was directly his fault or due to his policies, and he will not change direction—although occasionally he’ll mouth the words people want to hear. But that’s only for brief moments before he returns to who he really is. And when he’s stressed, he will increase his negative behavior rather than decrease it.
He Will Never Fire Hegseth
Pete Hegseth is the most like Trump of all his Cabinet appointments. He is really an avatar for Trump. Before he was nominated for Secretary of Defense (he calls himself Secretary of War), he wrote a book The War on Warriors: Behind the Betrayal of the Men Who Keep Us Free. In it he appears to think, feel, act, and talk like Trump.
“Powerful leftists have leveraged their disdain for America to systematically confuse, neuter, and weaken the greatest fighting force for good this world has ever seen…. Their goal was stated very clearly by Barack Obama: fundamentally transform America. You don’t fundamentally transform something you disdain. As Mark Levin recently documented, the Democratic Party really does hate America. Our Constitution, our flag, our faith, and our creeds.”
All of these words sound like Trump and blaming everything on Obama totally fits too. He has always based many of his policies on nothing other than to reverse what Obama did.
As I suggested in a prior post, Hegseth may demonstrate grandiose narcissism, which includes a drive to prove that he is superior by tearing down the efforts and values of those who came before him. This personality may drive his every action, from firing numerous non-white, non-male generals and commanders (during wartime no less); to demanding that generals stationed around the world come home to a meeting so he could harass and demean them; to proving that he can physically work out with the troops: to maintaining a slick TV image in everything he does.
Trump loves to watch Hegseth humiliate and dominate everyone. Hegseth is all image – the image Trump loves. Trump loves watching TV and Hegseth provides good TV. Firing him would be like firing himself. When efforts last week to bring articles of impeachment against Hegseth failed in the House last week, Trump said: “Pete Hegseth gets an ‘A’ PLUS, PLUS, PLUS for his defense against a disgruntled, angry, defeated, former Congressman, Thomas Massie, a TOTAL LOSER” as reported by The Hill. It will take others to remove him.
Why He Promotes Steven Miller
Last week, Trump announced that his Chief of Staff, Susie Wiles, was stepping down and that his Deputy Chief of Staff for Policy and Homeland Security, Steven Miller, would become his next Chief of Staff. Steven Miller is another avatar for Trump, but he is more extreme than Trump. Miller has the words that Trump loves. Watching and listening to Miller appears to be endlessly enjoyable for him. He will never fire him either.
In their book Regime Change, Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan explained their relationship:
“Trump loved Miller’s bulldog mentality, his instinct to turn the dial up on controversy, and his way of framing issues and acting on them in blunt, Godfather-inflected language…. When Trump wanted something done, Miller would tell him that he would do it immediately, presenting himself as a man of action rather than the traditional bureaucrat consulting with departments and lawyers before coming back to the President with options.” (page 25)
Miller appears to also have a narrow-range personality, with his paranoid and sadist approach to rounding up immigrants as the person in charge of ICE policy. Data obtained by the CATO Institute showed that less than 30% of immigrants arrested by ICE have any criminal record (mostly traffic-related) and only 5% have a violent criminal record. However, Miller has said at various times that immigrants (even ones with legal, protected status) are “heinous monsters,” “rapists,” “murderers,” “kidnappers,” and “sexual assaulters” and should be detained and deported.
In 2024, during a discussion of rounding up immigrants, “Trump remarked that if it were left to Miller there would be only 100 million people in the United States [instead of the current 340 million] and they would all look like Stephen Miller.” (Haberman & Swan, page 99) Trump appears to enjoy Miller being seen as even more extreme than himself. It makes him look more reasonable while letting Miller do his dirty work.
The Reality
Trump will be Trump. There has been little variation in the past sixteen years. It’s common for people to think that now – after each extreme event – Trump will become reasonable. He has not “learned his lesson” and cannot stop himself. Now it’s up to the Democrats to not be naïve. Only they can stop the war and put an end to ICE, as well as improving the lives of Americans through legislation. It’s time for setting limits and imposing consequences on a dangerous President who can’t stop himself.




