70th Anniversary of Pearl Harbor – December 7, 1941 : What It Means to Us Today – Open Thread

by on December 7, 2011 · 5 comments

in History, Veterans, War and Peace

While recalling my father in WWII, I wonder what he would think of our lack of First Amendment rights today?

Today is the 70th anniversary of the attack at Pearl Harbor which pushed the U.S. into World War Two.  The Japanese surprise dismantled a good part of the US Pacific Fleet. Whether FDR knew about the coming attack is not our concern today.

Our concern today – expressed by an Open Thread – is what it means for us so many decades later, when most of that generation have taken their leave from this world.

If my father was still alive, he would remind us that he heard about the attack at Pearl Harbor coming out of a movie theater in the Boston area.  He was already in uniform, as part of the Massachusetts National Guard.  He was ordered that day to report immediately to his unit.  And he was in one of the first contingent of American troops to be shipped out — to Australia initially, as somebody high up thought the Japanese were going to attack that huge continent. My father, who was an Army officer for most of his career, spent the war in the Pacific, battling machine gun nests and malaria. He fought at Guadalcanal and on other islands with names that previously had no meaning to a country coming out of the Great Depression.

Lucky for me, he made it. Although at one point, as he would later recount to me while in a hospital bed weakened by his family’s famous heart 3 decades later, that in one battle he was ordered to take out a machine gun nest, a machine gun nest that two earlier attacks had failed to dislodge.  He told his captain, all right sir, and gave the captain his watch, as he didn’t think he would need it any longer.

He did make it, as you can see by the type-written words of his son many moons later.

My father didn’t have a political bone in his body, being career army, but he wasn’t  gung-ho. He never kept a gun at home and while I lived with him for nearly two decades, he never came across as a war-monger or saber-rattler. I guess he had seen enough war, as he also went to Korea in 1950 to fight on that peninsula, while the rest of the family took up residence in Point Loma.

Yet, I wonder what he would think today, watching how police departments and big-city mayors all over this country routinely squash the American rights and freedoms that he and his generation fought for.  The Occupy Wall Street movement – if nothing else – has shown the limits of freedoms of expression, assembly and free press that our current society permits.  And they are downright pitiful.

What would his generation of soldiers have thought when protesters could not even set up tents as a form of freedom of expression?  When protesters are arrested for trying to register people to vote, when protesters are arrested for staying in a public plaza? When demonstrators are arrested for laying on the ground?  When citizens are rounded up because the grass they were staying on was dead?  When mainstream reporters are arrested while police trample on peoples’ rights? When public plazas and parks are no long safe refuge for the expression of dissent?

I hope he would be royally pissed off.  I’ll ask him when I see him again.

What are your thoughts and/or memories? Let us know in the comments below.

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

avatar DH December 7, 2011 at 12:20 pm

I bet those soldiers, who went through war, would be pissed off at all the hippies whining and bitching about their “terrible” circumstances in life. And doing nothing but setting up tent cities and smoking weed.

Reply

avatar Goatskull December 8, 2011 at 6:18 am

Maybe you’re not aware of this, but there are quite a few vets among the OWS movement. If this is surprising to you than you haven’t been paying much attention. As to surviving the soldiers, sailors, and airmen from WWII, they were from a different time frame and a very different set of circumstances, so understandably they might not relate to the whole OWS movement.

Reply

avatar Brian December 8, 2011 at 7:28 am

It is my opinion that the patriotism of the time is something that is sorely missed in todays society. This can be seen in both a diminished expression of rights or an increase in fashionable apathy towards the country in which we live in. Our fathers and grandfathers who fought in this war were eager to serve the great country we live in, and were proud to do it. There are still soldiers who do this today, but look at how many citizens run as fast as they can from serving. I am proud to be a grandson of a man who fought in the war, and proud to live in the country he served.

Reply

avatar Frank Gormlie December 8, 2011 at 11:15 am

I think that one of the messages from the soldiers and sailors who fought in WWII would be: “Don’t go to war.”

We’ve had so many imperial military misadventures since that war, that in no way does honoring those who fought in that war and in remembering Pearl Harbor serve as an honorarium to our wars in general and the wars in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq and now Afghanistan – in fact, quiet the opposite.

There are many vets in the Occupy movement, as well as there are many vets among the homeless population – at least one quarter.

And there are many good reasons for honest, patriotic young people to “flee” from military service – for starters, they don’t wish to be fodder for the Pentagon and the corporations. But alas, there is an economic draft, and many young people without material means to support themselves, see the military as a job of last resort.

Reply

avatar Nicholoas G. Cook December 8, 2011 at 3:23 pm

I would like to lern more about december 7,1941. if you or eney familymemder knows eney life storys pleas E-mail me at Nickcook122395@gmail.com.

P.S.
this is a school project so pleas E-mail me as soon as you can
Thank You = )

Reply

Leave a Comment

Before clicking Submit, please complete this simple statement to help us weed out the bots... Thank you! *

Older Article:

Newer Article: