San Diego’s City Council District 8 – Martinez vs Moreno: It’s Complicated

by on September 20, 2018 · 2 comments

in San Diego

The district is a bi-polar political entity. Geography and long-standing loyalties both exert a significant influence on elections in the city’s southernmost political sector.

City Council District 8 is bisected by National City & Chula Vista. The north and south ends have a majority Latino population in common, but the external realities differ.

The forces of gentrification weight heavily on neighborhoods connected to the core city like Barrio Logan. The border with Mexico, along with the militarization that goes with it, looms over the southern end.

Overlaid on these different environments are family and personal connections. To understand the race for city council in District 8, a history lesson is in order. I’ve simplified parts of this story because the nuances are near-impossible for an outsider to discern.

District 8

Communities: Barrio Logan, Egger Highlands, Grant Hill, Logan Heights, Memorial, Nestor, Ocean View Hills, Otay Mesa East, Otay Mesa West, San Ysidro, Shelltown, Sherman Heights, Stockton, Tijuana River Valley

Registered Democrats have a better than a three-to-one advantage over Republicans in the district, and the GOP didn’t bother to field a candidate for the June primary.

The contest for San Diego City Council in 2018 is a manifestation of a long-simmering feud symbolized by the animus between termed-out D8 Councilman David Alvarez and State Senator Ben Hueso.

Alvarez is the upstart whose actions have defied political convention.

Alvarez won his council seat when he beat Felipe Hueso, brother of the State Senator, in 2010. He’s currently running for a position on the Community College Board of Trustees. It’s no secret Alvarez will abandon the post (should he win) for a shot at Greg Cox’s County Supervisor seat when the incumbent is termed out in 2020. Ben Hueso would also reportedly like a shot at the same seat.

Mural in Chicano Park Credit nathangibbs / Flickr

The District 8 Councilman ran for Mayor in 2014 with the backing of then-labor council president and would-be progressive political kingmaker Mickey Kasparian.

Then Alvarez crossed his former backer, soliciting a political contribution from Lincoln Club Political Affairs Committee chair (and now former Republican) David Malcolm, whose fortune comes from Suncoast Financial Mortgage.

Kasparian, still serving as president of the United Foodservice and Commercial Workers, fell from grace from the Labor Council amid accusation of sexual harassment and political malpractice. He started a rump group, the Working Families Council, with a couple of other breakaway unions, and is considered politically toxic in most progressive circles.

Alvarez staffer Vivian Moreno is his anointed candidate to replace him. Her challenger, San Ysidro School Board member Antonio Martinez, is backed by allies of Ben Hueso and the Working Families Council.

Vivian Moreno (Democrat)

Website | Facebook | Twitter
Total amount raised by candidate thru June: $165,516

Issues: Keep our neighborhoods safe by putting more police officers on the street, Create jobs and grow our economy by attracting more investment in our communities, Fix our streets and sidewalks and build more parks and playgrounds for our kids.

Organizational Endorsements: San Diego County Young Democrats, San Diego Municipal Employees Association (MEA), California Young Democrats (CYD), San Diego Union-Tribune, Sierra Club San Diego, Run Women Run, San Diego Democrats for Equality, San Diego Environmental Democrats, San Diego County Apartment Association, Democratic Women’s Club.

Union-Tribune San Diego City Council candidate Vivian Moreno on the issues
KPBSVivian Moreno Wants More Housing, Transit Options In District 8
San Diego ReaderCandidates square off for Alvarez’s council seat

On paper, there’s little to distinguish the politics of the candidates. Moreno has come out against the idea of rent control, a position possibly connected to the copious amounts of money contributed to her effort by real estate interests.

While both candidates are vocal about “keeping our communities safe,” the nod from law enforcement establishment political action groups has gone to Martinez.

Moreno, on the other hand, was the beneficiary of a July 31 fundraiser whose hosts included Irene Rodriguez, married to National City Police Chief Manny Rodriguez. I’m not sure this constitutes an endorsement by the controversial cop, but the folks who forwarded me the invitation to the Achiote Restaurant event certainly did.

Antonio Martinez (Democrat)

Website | Facebook | Twitter
Total amount raised by candidate thru June: $88,525

Issues: Our Community’s Fair Share, Helping Every Child Succeed, Healthy, Safe Communities, Protecting South Bay Families

Organizational Endorsements: San Diego County Democratic Party, San Ysidro Teachers Association, Southwest Regional Council of Carpenters, San Diego Police Officers Association, United Association of Plumbers, Steamfitters and HVAC/R Local 230, San Diego City Fire Fighters, Deputy City Attorneys Association of San Diego, Planned Parenthood Action Fund of the Pacific Southwest, San Ysidro Classified School Employees Association, San Diego Working Families Council, Unite Here Local 30

Union-TribuneSan Diego City Council candidate Antonio Martinez on the issues
Times of San DiegoSecond Primary Opponent Endorses Martinez for City Council District 8
Times of San DiegoDemocratic Council Members Endorse Different Candidates

Martinez has the support of much–but not all–of the Democratic Party establishment. He got the party’s official blessing, which means its member communications pipeline now includes support for the Martinez campaign. What this means in terms of financial support will not be reported until later in the season, so quantifying it isn’t possible now.

So, when it comes time to vote, as best as I can determine, it’s really not about the candidates. It’s about what faction they represent. The Martinez website has a virtual catalog of politicos backing him. On the other hand, there’s the toxicity of Kasparian, whose ongoing battle with Latina activists makes any candidate he supports a no-go for many progressives.

Martinez and the two other candidates running in the June primary received 63% of the vote. Both Christain Ramirez and Zach Lazarus have endorsed his candidacy.

The Moreno website doesn’t have an endorsement page; I had to go digging through Facebook posts for what I’m sure was an incomplete list. While I normally don’t list individuals backing candidates on my posts, I think it is significant that Moreno is endorsed by Councilmember Georgette Gomez

Some of the Democratic party activists I spoke with on background for this story told me she had an “entitled attitude” in asking for support that cost her backing. Certainly, there is a long history in San Diego of political staffers replacing their bosses, and Alvarez has gone all-in drumming up support for Vivian Moreno.

Like I said, it’s complicated.

This was first published at San Diego Free Press.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Lori Saldana September 21, 2018 at 5:58 pm

Campaigns are about the future, yet this article is buried in the past. It could have provided readers with some insight about how these young candidates hope to represent their community in the years to come. Instead, it focussed on how others have battled over the last decade.

The author writes: “So, when it comes time to vote, as best as I can determine, it’s really not about the candidates. It’s about what faction they represent. ”

Nonsense. All politics are personal. Did anyone even try to talk to either candidate for this report? There are no personal statements. No direct quotes. No insights into the reasons these two young people are running for office in one of the nation’s largest cities, along a border with many challenges: cross border sewage flows, private immigrant detention facilities with inhumane child separation policies, border fence construction follies…

What are their views on even one of these issues that impacts the families in their district?

Instead- in a community still plagued by overt racism (see “Border Patriot” attacks on Chicano Park), income inequality, homelessness, gentrification, and a myriad of public safety concerns- this report rehashes old political battles that few residents of D8 likely care about.

I wish both candidates well, and hope they are taken more seriously by others who write about this campaign.


John Thickstun September 23, 2018 at 10:43 am

It’s not complicated at all.
If you care about your neighborhood, your neighbors, affordable housing, public schools, San Diego’s economy – all of which are adversely impacted by short term vacation rental – Antonio Martinez is the candidate you should support.

Vivian Moreno has not only accepted thousands of dollars in campaign donations from real estate interests, she’s received tens of thousands of dollars from Airbnb and its lobbyists, Craig Benedetto of California Strategies and Chris Wahl of Southwest Strategies, along with STVR owners and operators, including Jonah Mechanic of Seabreeze Vacation Rentals, his wife, Venessa Neff of Sunny Days Enterprises, Nancy Kramer of Nancy’s Vacation Rentals and Paul Becker of Bluewater Vacation Homes.

Save San Diego Neighborhoods endorsed Antonio Martinez before the primary, because he is committed to pushing for enforcement of the San Diego Municipal Code when he is elected.
You won’t find Airbnb lobbyists or STVR operators/owners on Antonio’s campaign disclosure forms.
Follow the money.


Leave a Comment

Older Article:

Newer Article: