U-T columnist Logan Jenkins
The Daily Fishwrap’s Logan Jenkins is one of their “columnists” who is supposed to put a human “spin” on the news. His take for Labor Day this year was one of the most uninformed and deliberately misleading columns I’ve read in a long time in the Union-Tribune. You have to go back to the early Copley days of the paper to find these kinds of distortions passed off as news.
Entitled “We’re a long way from the Labor Day of the Spreckels era”, the column starts out by purporting to tell us about how tough things were for organized labor 99 years ago, when the Industrial Workers of the World (Wobblies) converged upon San Diego. He fails to note that the local robber barons were motivated to crack down of the Wobblies initially because they had the nerve to try and organize streetcar (the Spreckels family owned the street car company and the Union-Tribune back then) workers, a group that other unions ignored because they were largely Mexican. The Wobblies organizing efforts turned into a series of confrontations that historians now call the San Diego Free Speech Fight.
Wobblies from all over the country poured into San Diego in support of the cause, and local jails were packed. The authorities ultimately were powerless in the face of the unrelenting pressure from the union. So, with the blessing of the local power structure, vigilante groups were allowed to enter the fray. That’s when things got ugly. (More on this here). Thus a long tradition of sub-rosa relationships between local law enforcement and vigilantes against local trouble makers began.
Jenkins goes on from misrepresenting the past, to telling his readers that the local AFL-CIO took Labor Day weekend off after having a Friday morning banquet.
Funny thing is, I just returned from Horton Plaza where better than three hundred members of a least six unions that I counted, joined with local activists in a protest demanding “Jobs Not Cuts”. Congressman (and Mayoral candidate) Bob Filner spoke, along with Congressional candidate Lori Saldana, AFL-CIO Secretary Lorena Gonzalez, and Frank Gormlie. There were TV crews from at least four local stations at the rally. And there was an earlier rally in support of the Grocery Workers just a few blocks away; the print edition of the paper even ran a teaser headline for a local scab tv station right next to Jenkins’ column.
But, according to Jenkins, “[local labor leaders] Wouldn’t want to clutter the long weekend with parades and fire-breathing speeches that, frankly, few would take the time to attend.”
Memo to Jenkins:
1) The times are changing around here. There’s this thing called the “internet”. Once you learn how to use it, you’ll discover sites like “Facebook”, “Twitter” and “Blogs”. Millions of people use them. (Why, nearly 80,000 people a month visit this lowly site.) Had you known about this internet thing, instead of ripping news off from another dead tree journalism project (The North County Times, I’m told was the source of your misinformation), you might have been aware that organized labor did indeed have actions on tap for Labor Day.
2) And you might even have learned that organized labor and community groups in San Diego are planning a centennial observance of the San Diego Free Speech Fight next January. I intend to be one of the voices atop the soap boxes along Broadway next winter, even though I’m battling throat cancer. I bet you’ll be hiding behind you desk down in Mission Valley while we’re orating.
{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }
You talking about this article, Doug?
Let me know: I’d like to make sure that I’ve attributed all work before I reblog your article.
yes. My bad. I left the link out of this draft. here’s the link to the UT column. http://goo.gl/OIbhq
I also read that article yesterday morning (Labor Day). It struck me as lazy journalism, combining both snark -“[San Diego and Imperial Counties Labor Council] Wouldn’t want to clutter the long weekend with parades and fire-breathing speeches that, frankly, few would take the time to attend. Why rally when you can kick back and grill?” and a broad splash of whitewash- “Issa has been ripped hardest for buying commercial property in his own district, which is nothing if not Main Street.”
Mr. Jenkins’ unfortunately comes across as cynical and misinformed. Perhaps he would have served both himself and his readers better by simply taking the day off.
The article was frankly forgotten as we prepared to join three hundred other people to listen to “fiery speeches” and stand together as a reminder of what Labor Day still means to us.
I’ve never ripped a columnist before, but this putz, Logan Jenkins, can’t see past the end of his nose. When he had his Volvo stolen (he fits that stereotype to a tee), he filled a few columns with smug, self-serving and none-too-interesting letters to the thief. Then there was the article about (shockingly) his own alma mater, Francis Parker School. Next he’ll describe his front porch and the backs of his hands. It beats working.